The Fayetteville, North Carolina community is mourning an unimaginable loss following the tragic deaths of Amanda Smith, 23, her mother Cheri Smith, 50, and her brother Erin Poole, 29. The three family members were killed during a violent incident at their home on N. Sumac Circle on the evening of January 25, 2026, a tragedy that has left loved ones and neighbors shaken and heartbroken.
According to the Fayetteville Police Department, officers were dispatched to the residence at approximately 9:35 p.m. after receiving reports of gunfire. Upon entering the home, officers discovered Cheri Smith, Erin Poole, and Amanda Smith suffering from gunshot wounds. Cheri and Erin were pronounced dead at the scene. Amanda was rushed to a local hospital with life-threatening injuries, where medical teams fought to save her life. Despite those efforts, Amanda later succumbed to her injuries.
Investigators reported that the incident stemmed from an altercation involving a known associate of the family, 25-year-old Nijyle Lewis. Authorities stated that multiple gunshots were fired and a stabbing occurred during the confrontation. Lewis sustained injuries and was transported to a local hospital for treatment. He has since been arrested and charged with three counts of First-Degree Murder in connection with the deaths. Police have confirmed the incident was isolated and that there is no ongoing threat to the public. The investigation remains active.
Beyond the devastating circumstances, Amanda, Cheri, and Erin are being remembered for the lives they lived and the love they shared as a family.
Amanda Smith, just 23 years old, is remembered as a warm, compassionate young woman who shared deep bonds with her family, friends, and neighbors. A devoted daughter and sister, Amanda was known for her kindness, her caring nature, and the joy she brought into the lives of those around her. Her smile, laughter, and gentle spirit left a lasting impression on everyone she met. Though her life was tragically cut short, the love she gave continues to live on in the hearts of those who knew her.
Cheri Smith, 50, was a loving mother whose life centered around caring for her children and family. She is remembered as a source of strength, guidance, and unconditional love. Those closest to her describe a woman who put family first and whose presence provided comfort and stability. Her loss leaves a profound void not only within her family, but among friends and community members who admired her devotion and heart.
Erin Poole, 29, is remembered as a beloved son and brother whose life was deeply intertwined with his family. Known for his loyalty and care for those he loved, Erin’s passing has left friends and relatives grieving the loss of a young man whose future was full of potential. His bond with his family was evident, and his memory will remain forever tied to the love they shared.
The loss of three members of the same family has sent shockwaves through Fayetteville. Neighbors and community members have come together in grief, offering condolences, prayers, and support to surviving loved ones. Vigils, messages of remembrance, and shared stories reflect a collective effort to honor the lives lost and to stand in solidarity with the family during this heartbreaking time.
While the legal process continues, the focus for many remains on remembering Amanda, Cheri, and Erin not for the violence that took their lives, but for who they were — a family bound by love, connection, and shared memories that will never be forgotten.
Anyone with information related to this case is urged to contact Detective B. Pleze at (910) 676-2596, or submit anonymous tips through Fayetteville / Cumberland County Crime Stoppers at (910) 483-TIPS (8477) or online at fay-nccrimestoppers.org.
Amanda Smith, Cheri Smith, and Erin Poole will be remembered with love, sorrow, and enduring respect. Their lives mattered, their absence is deeply felt, and their memory will forever remain in the hearts of those who knew and loved them.
Leave a Reply